My family had a great time relaxing at the carriage house for four days over the Christmas and New Year period. The house and the property are well maintained and well supplied (which has been rare since the pandemic). The owner/manager even provided coffee, cream, juice, champagne, nuts, cheese snack, and I probably missed a few. We appreciated these small extras, esp. the cream since we have many coffee drinkers in our family.
The property is located in the most centrally located spot that we have ever rented. You can easily walk to everything in the French Quarter and Downtown, which is great because parking can be expensive in the area. For the first three days there, we did not even move our car, which is parked right on the property.
If I visit Charleston again, this will be my #1 choice. It's truly hard to beat.