This house was very nice - clean when we arrived. Good sized bedrooms, bathrooms, kitchen, and common areas. Easy check in, and like everything in Ohiopyle, a stone's throw from all the outdoor rec you need. TV, wi-fi, appliances, etc. all worked great.
Going with 4 stars instead of 5 for just a couple small-ish reasons. With the high price of the rental and the limited range of food options in town, it would be really great if the kitchen had a cupboard for the owners or renters to stock a basic pantry. We found just salt and pepper shakers. There's no grocery store in town and all of the restaurants just serve pretty basic pub grub. For those looking to take advantage of the kitchen, would be nice if you didn't have to bring every last cooking supply and instead had a cupboard with a few leftover spices or cooking oils or other basics.
Second, there is no central AC so most of the rooms have window units. Ours was a little noisey at night running at the power level necessary to cool off the room - took the fun out of listening to a midnight thunderstorm roll through or the quiet of the wilderness in the early morning.